1 by Two-A review

Some films keep you at the edge of your seat while some others challenge your grey cells. Seldom has one come across a film that does both.1 by two is such a film. A well-crafted thriller it requires effort on the part of the viewer to make sense of what is unfolding in front of you. Twin brothers HariNarayanan & Ravinarayanan played by Murali Gopy   share an intimate relationship.Harinarayanan meets with a fatal accident & dies while rushing to attend a patient .His twin brother tries to commit suicide overwhelmed by the news of Hari’s death. Things go haywire when Ravi claims that he is Hari & starts behaving like him. Even their businessman father (Azhagar Perumal) claims that it is Hari who survived . Inspector Yusuf Marikar (Fahad Fazil) who chanced upon Hari’s body at the accident site suspects foul play. Yusuf is certain that it is Ravi who has survived & letting him loose will lead to chaos. He sets out to unravel the mystery with a missionary zeal. Which of the brother is dead? Why is Yusuf obsessed with this case? The rest of the movie tries to answer these questions. The fine thriller examines the effect of certain incidents on one’s psyche. The films has some memorable sequences  of  how emotions can  get the better of one’s judgement.Jeyamohan’s fine script is backed by power packed performances by the lead actors, deft editing & stunning cinematography by Jomon Thomas.Gopi Sunder’s background score compliments the storyline. Murali Gopy breathes life to the twin characters he plays. He is at his best during the climax of the movie .Fahad Fazil does justice to his role & brings out the vulnerabilities of the character he essays. Honey Rose gets a meaty role but fails to rise up to the challenge.Shyamaprasad effortlessly plays the role of the Psychiatrist DrCherian.However the film is not without its share of  flaws. The film tries to pack too much for its running time of 2.5 hours.  It drifts through issues ranging from illegal drug testing to transference to the effect of a traumatic incident during childhood on one’s personality.  And Fahad Fazil’s character is inspired by Aamir Khan’s role in Talash.Atleast a couple of Fahad’s sequences are heavily inspired if not rip offs from Talash.1 by Two is definitely worth a try .Some of us might feel  overwhelmed like the characters in the movie. Nevertheless, this film will make you sit back & reflect long after you leave the theater.

The unviability of a Third Front

As BJP’s chance of coming back to power is getting brighter & brighter the prospects of a Third Front government has gone like a puff of smoke. If opinion polls are to be believed, BJP & its allies are going to get anywhere between 200 to 220 seats & with this kind of numbers finding allies would not be a problem at all. Therefore, the question in one’s mind is why a strong third front has not emerged even though there is ample space for it in Indian politics.After all people are tried of voting congress & BJP whose policies are more or less the same. First & foremost, there has never been a genuine Third Front in Indian politics. The so called Third Front governments which  had  brief stints earlier came to power  either with support of congress or the BJP.The  Janata Party which came to power in 1977 was a grand coalition of disgruntled elements in the congress at that time ,Jan Sangh  & others. Charan Singh  toppled the government with the support of the congress&succeeded it. Charan Singh could not prove his majority in the parliament & headed one of the most short-lived governments in the history of the country. In 1989, V.P.Singh government came to power with support of BJP & the Left .It fell after 11 months when BJP pulled its plug. Chandra Shekhar who missed the chance of becoming the Prime Minister a couple of times  earlier & whose only ambition in life was to sit at the PM’s chair even it was  for a day  formed the government with congress support. The government fell within 40 days when Congress withdrew its support on a lame excuse that Rajiv Gandhi was being spied on by the CID. The Third front got another shot in power when the 13-day Vajpayee government fell in 1996.The then Karnataka Chief Minister Deve Gowda headed the government after V.P.Singh refused & CPI(M) denied Jyoti Basu the chance to head the government. Soon Sitaram Kesri the then Congress who got tired of Gowda showed him the door & replaced him with I.K.Gujral.Gujral government met the same fate once congress felt that it had outlived its utility. The Third front is a substitute front popped either by the BJP or by Congress to keep the other out of power. The constituents of the Third front with the exception of left parties do not present an alternative vision for the country. The other constituent members of the Third front have in the past aligned with either of the two national parties for their own self-serving reasons. Therefore, the chances of them ditching Left to join either of the two alliances is a possibility no one can rule out. Moreover, with the Left’s chances expanding its base from its strongholds remains weak the chances of a Third alternative remains a pipe dream.

An ode to AMMA

It is often said that not all successful people were outstanding in school & not all outstanding students go on to do well in life. However, there are a lucky few who have done both. Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Jayalalithaa is one such person. Though she has never gone to college she was a brilliant student who excelled both in academics & in extracurricular activities while studying at Sacred Hearts girls’ school in Chennai. And her life has been one that most people can only dream about. A glamorous & wildly successful film star in her prime she has the distinction of starring the maximum number of films with her mentor MGR. Her political career is no less outstanding. She has the rare distinction of being the First woman Leader of Opposition in Tamil Nadu Assembly & the first elected woman Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu besides being youngest person to occupy the post. A three time Chief Minister, she has set her eyes for the top job in Delhi. Regardless of whether she becomes the reigning queen or kingmaker in Delhi there is no doubt that she has in her to become a good Prime Minister. Unlike Sonia Gandhi whose surname helped her to gain mileage or Mayawati whose mentor Kanshi Ram was instrumental in shaping her career, Jaya had to fight it out from the beginning. Though MGR her political Godfather helped her to get a Rajya Sabha seat & appointed her as the propaganda Secretary of the party his ill health during his last years made him inaccessible to her. After MGR’s death in 1987 senior leaders in the party expelled her & installed MGR’S widow Janaki Ramachandran as the Chief Minister. This lead to a split in the party into two factions one supporting MGR’s widow & the other favouring Jayalalithha.  Jaya finally emerged as the undisputed leader of AIADMK after the 1989 assembly elections when the two factions merged. As the Leader of Opposition, she was physically assaulted inside the assembly she vowed that she would enter the assembly only as the Chief Minister .The DMK was defeated in the next assembly elections & did not win a single seat in the General elections held in the same year. Though her first term is best remembered for multiple scams & her excesses she did introduce some good schemes like the cradle baby scheme as a response to the killing of the girl child at birth, all women police stations & 30% reservation for women in police jobs. Though she was defeated in the next assembly elections, she even lost her seat she made a stunning comeback in 2001.With time Jayalalithaa has matured, as a politician for the first time there has not been a big scam or controversy in her term. She has even managed to keep the voters in her side with a slew of welfare schemes like  Amma canteen which serves hugely subsidized meals, twenty kilos of rice for each BPL family, free mixie-grinders & fans, bicycles for school kids, full scholarships for students who do well in schools, sari and a taali (mangalsutra) for girls getting married.She has become even more shrewder in her calculations she courted the left by backing their candidates for the Rajya Sabha before showing  the door when she was convinced  about their lack of utility. One politician she resembles is Indira Gandhi both had to fight with senior leaders to gain control of their parties, both made comebacks after losing elections badly & both are manifestly dictatorial. Moreover, like Indira Gandhi whose core constituency was the economically poor Jaya is wooing the downtrodden with an effective PDS system & a slew of other welfare measures. A regional satrap at the top of her form she is hoping to do to DMK what she did to them in 1991 & what it did to her in 2004.But it won’t be a smooth ride for her, BJP has cobbled up a coalition consisting of Vijayakant’s DMDK, PMK & Vaiko’s MDMK which between them won 22% of votes in the last elections. This rainbow coalition could be a spoiler for her Prime Ministerial ambitions. But her political career is marked by contradictions she is woman in the males den of Tamil Nadu politics that too a Brahmin who heads a party which is an offshoot of the anti-Brahmin movement. Whether she finally wears the crown or not she is here to stay.